Can two serial cheaters get a second chance at love? After a one-night stand in college, New Yorkers Lainey and Jake meet by chance twelve years later and discover they each have the same problem: because of their monogamy-challenged ways, neither can maintain a relationship. Determined to stay friends despite their mutual attraction, they make a pact to keep it platonic, a deal that proves easier said than done.
![]() |
Alison Brie | Lainey |
![]() |
Jason Sudeikis | Jake |
![]() |
Jordan Carlos | R.A. |
![]() |
Margarita Levieva | Hannah |
![]() |
Charles Cain | Helmet Kid |
![]() |
Adam Brody | Sam |
![]() |
Michael Cyril Creighton | Attentive Waiter |
![]() |
Billy Eichner | SLAA Speaker |
![]() |
Jason Mantzoukas | Xander |
![]() |
Amanda Peet | Paula |
![]() |
Victoria Frings | Nurse |
![]() |
Adam Scott | Matthew |
![]() |
Natasha Lyonne | Kara |
![]() |
Andrea Savage | Naomi |
![]() |
Sawyer Shipman | Lyle |
![]() |
Anna Margaret Hollyman | Renee |
![]() |
Margaret Odette | Thea |
![]() |
Carlo Alban | Microcenter Employee |
![]() |
Remy Nozik | George |
![]() |
Jamil Mena | Big Dude |
![]() |
Marc Blucas | Chris |
![]() |
Austin Ku | Pho Grand Waiter |
![]() |
Katherine Waterston | Emma |
![]() |
Skylar Gaertner | Oliver |
![]() |
Mitchell Green | Police Officer |
Director | Leslye Headland |
![]() |
Writer | Leslye Headland | |
Producer | Matt Berenson, Kathryn Dean, Jessica Elbaum, Will Ferrell, Carla Hacken, Leslye Headland, Sidney Kimmel, Adam McKay, Mark Mikutowicz, Michael Sledd, Dylan Tarason, Jim Tauber, Bruce Toll | |
Musician | Andrew Feltenstein, John Nau | |
Photography | Ben Kutchins |