Priscilla Herschberger has been friends with Elam in their Amish community, since childhood. David Morgan is an outsider of the modern world, who travels frequently nearby to visit his grandparents. He is thinking of joining the Amish church. When Elam begins to pursue Priscilla, he rages with jealousy when he realizes that David could stand in the way of his planned proposal. Is it possible for Priscilla to forgive Elam after tragedy strikes, so love and trust could grow again?